selig wrote:Aquila wrote:Well I have to say I'm much happier with this announcement than I was with v8.
I'm still mildly disappointed that commonly requested features like expanded Combinator, rack zooming and Rewire weren't addressed though. But the colour themes and player tools seem to be satisfactory enough to warrant an upgrade (although budget limitations means I can't do that any time soon)
As has been said by the Props any time a feature is called "commonly requested", we must remember that we are a very small sub-set of the entire Reason user base. We have almost 2600 members here, and we can only imagine what a small fraction this represents of the entire user base. And of those 2600 members, a small fraction make feature suggestions. And of that group, only a small fraction ask for the same feature!
So it's a "numbers thing" - we THINK our suggestions make sense to everyone, but everyone works differently and has different needs. For example, I believe auto-punch is an all-important feature, but theres's only a handful of folks here that actively agree with me!
And I have to assume that the Props do some pretty intensive market research, despite the fact that many new features aren't things I'd often ever really need myself.
And can I also add that a darker theme, note razoring, audio to MIDI etc. ARE commonly requested features, so it's not like they are ignoring ALL commonly requested features…
Just trying to provide a little perspective here…
Yeah there are so many people with so many first priority wishes. But Auto Punch is a good example. I am waiting for this too, heck i have made a workable loopback combinator which gives me what i want in an okish way (it has to be adjusted for every tempo which is unhandy and is complicated to setup).But one would think it doesnt really take that much developer time to implement it if i can do it via Remote and a Combinator.
Another thing is PDC for inserts. If stuff can be fixed with the ms-delay RE then why cant this be integrated easily. I am aware of complicated latencies on intertwined stuff spread across the rack but for simple insert effects one would think this is a no brainer.
So people are wondering why there aren't more of the smaller but ultimately usefull features in updates.
Props usually do the big features pretty well but imho there should be more detail improvements in the point updates. Sure there are things where one might think this and that should be done in no time when it actually is pretty complicated but among these are probably a lot of wishes that can indeed be implemented quickly.
For example, was i happy when they added new remotables for Redrum, i asked for that for years and having Redrum on my launchpad is just awesome and then they added this blue button which creates a sequencer track for any device for which i also asked for. So last update i was lucky on two "small things" they did just for me lol. But those two alone made me upgrade when i was a bit disappointed of 8.0.
All in all i still like the update. I like the Players alot and i think they have alot of potential (anyone developing a looper player device please?). I am passing on with the audio stuff - not my cup of teas but i see alot of people wanting this. I dont say no to 1000 patches. But as said, if there was autopunch i would be very very happy again