gak wrote: The bass sim is good IF you kill the cab and like the direct sound. Very "hi-fi" and flexible. The guitar one is imho AWFUL. It's brittle, inflexible, and even with cab IR's it doesn't sound right.
The kuassa stuff is much much better, but there is a flaw: Weird aliasing with high notes (noticable when bending)
I gave up
I'm using a floor box (like line 6 firehawk) with eq and though it's not super omg perfect, it's plenty good enough. No cpu hit, forces you to play the part and not over tweak
and I use fx in reason
But I want them all. I want options!!!!!!
You're not wrong
No GR is understandable, but it sounds rubbish and isn't missed anyway. But the lack of anyone else porting (IK, looking at you especially!) is a bit baffling.
Having got all three Kuassa's (which do sound good, although I'm not aware of an aliasing problem, but in practice I've not used them enough to find out) and the two Softubes (which are utterly abysmal - any sound you want so long as it's either the boomy** one or the scratchy one. Well, thanks!), I still use PodFarm via the L6 rack devices. All the current options have their limitations, but the removal of PF with no viable alternative is very disappointing. One thing alone makes PF more usable to me - the Drive control.
In the new RE alternatives there's no easy way to internally control drive: you can select a high gain model, but that ends up providing a lot or too much terms of distortion. For low gain models, you can't really drive them so you have too little distortion. So then one always has to additional devices. I prefer the path of least resistance
It is a shame the L6 devices were so misunderstood, and from the start beginning weren't really implemented properly in Record; if they'd been a little bit more generous with the amp/cab combos—with better models than those rather naff default choices—and included at least the miking component, I suspect they'd have been better liked. As it was I get the feeling that for a lot of users they came across as just an advert for buying the full product.
Now if L6 introduced a dedicated RE version - with some kind of x-grade offer to PF owners, I'd be OK with that. But I think that's in the NGH category alongside GR and IK. As it stands now I either don't upgrade to Reason 9, or I'll have to run 8 and 9 depending on whether I need a decent amp or not.
** autocorrect suggested "Bosomy". Yeah, that'd work too